Editorial
Sources & Editorial Method
This page explains how exhibits are researched, written, cited and corrected. It is a statement of method, not a claim that every sentence in the museum has been formally peer reviewed.
Research and editorial principles
- A claim is written only when at least one identifiable published source supports it.
- Narrative style never overrides the evidence. Where the record is thin, the text says so.
- Contested national memory is presented with its plurality intact, without adopting a partisan voice.
- Oral tradition is valued and labelled as oral tradition rather than presented as documentary record.
Source hierarchy
When sources disagree, they are weighed in this order, with the higher level preferred unless a specific reason is stated in the exhibit.
- Primary sources: archival documents, inscriptions, period photography, contemporaneous press, and first-hand testimony.
- Academic secondary sources: peer reviewed books, journal articles and reference encyclopedias.
- Institutional references: museums, national archives, heritage agencies and recognized sporting federations.
- International bodies and heritage listings such as UNESCO World Heritage records.
- Quality journalism and documentary work, used for recent events and for cultural or sporting memory.
Citation standards
- Sources are defined once in a shared registry and referenced by exhibits, so the same work is never described in two conflicting ways.
- Each record carries a title, a kind, a publisher or archive when known, and a public link when one exists.
- Exhibits display a confidence label so a visitor can tell verified fact from widely accepted account, ongoing academic debate, or tradition.
Disputed and evolving interpretations
Dates, place names and casualty figures vary between traditions and archives. Where a figure is contested, the exhibit states the range and names the disagreement instead of choosing silently. Interpretations are revised when new scholarship becomes available.
Translation review
- English, French and Arabic carry the same facts. A translation may adapt phrasing but may not add, soften or remove a claim.
- Names of people and places keep their Amazigh, Arabic or French forms where those forms are the ones used in the sources.
- Machine assisted drafts are never published as final text without a human editorial pass.
Corrections policy
Reports of a factual error are reviewed against the cited sources. Confirmed errors are corrected in all three languages, and the source list of the exhibit is updated when the correction rests on a new reference. Where a report reflects a genuine scholarly dispute rather than an error, the exhibit is reworded to present both readings.
Images and media attribution
- Archival photographs are credited to their collection or photographer when that information is known.
- Illustrative or reconstructed imagery, including generated visuals used to evoke a place or a period, is labelled as illustrative and is never presented as a historical document.
- If a rights holder identifies an item that should be credited differently or withdrawn, the item is reviewed and updated.
Public source registry
These are the published works and institutional records the museum cites. Only public, publishable records appear here. Studio notes, drafts and internal review material are never shown.
Primary sources
Archives nationales d'outre-mer (ANOM)
Aix-en-Provence, France
Open sourceThe Muqaddimah
Ibn Khaldūn · 1377
Archives
Gallica — Bibliothèque nationale de France
BnF
Open sourceBibliothèque nationale d'Algérie
République algérienne
Open sourceOffice de Protection et de Promotion de la Vallée du M'Zab (OPVM)
Ministry of Culture, Algeria
Open source
Academic references
Numidia — Encyclopædia Britannica
Encyclopædia Britannica
Open sourceMasinissa, king of Numidia — Britannica
Encyclopædia Britannica
Open sourceThe Berbers
Michael Brett & Elizabeth Fentress · Blackwell (Peoples of Africa series) · 1996
Modern Algeria: The Origins and Development of a Nation
John Ruedy · Indiana University Press · 2005
Histoire de l'Algérie coloniale (1830–1954)
Benjamin Stora · La Découverte · 2004
Encyclopédie berbère
Gabriel Camps (dir.) · Édisud / OpenEdition
Open sourceA Savage War of Peace: Algeria 1954–1962
Alistair Horne · New York Review Books · 1977
Le M'Zab, une leçon d'architecture
André Ravéreau · Sindbad / Actes Sud · 1981
Habiter le désert : les maisons mozabites
Catherine & Pierre Donnadieu, Hubert Didillon · Mardaga · 1986
The Ibāḍī Tradition and the Making of the Rustamid Imamate
Virginie Prevost · Peeters · 2010
Museums and collections
Musée national du Bardo — Algiers
Ministère de la Culture
Musée public national Cirta
Constantine, Algeria
Département des Antiquités — Musée du Louvre
Musée du Louvre
Open source
International and heritage bodies
Timgad — UNESCO World Heritage Centre
UNESCO
Open sourceDjémila — UNESCO World Heritage Centre
UNESCO
Open sourceKasbah of Algiers — UNESCO World Heritage Centre
UNESCO
Open sourceTassili n'Ajjer — UNESCO World Heritage Centre
UNESCO
Open sourceCouscous — Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity (UNESCO 2020)
UNESCO · 2020
Open sourceM'Zab Valley — UNESCO World Heritage Centre
UNESCO · 1982
Open sourceConserving Earthen Architecture — M'Zab Case Study
Getty Conservation Institute
Open source
Media and documentary
El Moudjahid — archival editions
El Moudjahid
Open sourceAlgérie Presse Service (APS)
APS
Open sourceLe Monde — archives
Le Monde
Open source
Football records
FIFA — Official records & tournaments
Fédération Internationale de Football Association
Open sourceCAF — Confederation of African Football
CAF
Open sourceFédération Algérienne de Football
FAF
Open sourceRSSSF — Rec.Sport.Soccer Statistics Foundation
RSSSF
Open sourceJS Kabylie — Club archives & communiqués
JS Kabylie
L'équipe FLN de football (1958–1962) — histoire et joueurs
Various historians · El Moudjahid & FAF archives
Women's Africa Cup of Nations — CAF
CAF
Open source
Further reading
A History of Algeria
James McDougall · Cambridge University Press · 2017
The Berbers and the Islamic State
Maya Shatzmiller · Markus Wiener · 2000
Le Corbusier — Œuvre complète (Sahara notebooks & M'Zab studies)
Le Corbusier · Éditions Girsberger / Birkhäuser · 1931–1957
Report a correction
A public contact channel for corrections is being prepared and will be published here.